Historical Figures In Fiction – Character And Cliche
Not Quite As You Remember Them
Human
history is a rich platter from which many a writer or developer has
plucked a fruit or two to help tell their own tales. However, in the
land of fiction few things remain true to fact for long and all such
historical figures end up deviating from their real life
counterparts. Over time
ideas about how to handle these characters started to clump together
and what was once truth inevitably becomes cliché. By far the most
common way this manifest is through an idealised presentation which
sands off the edges from the real person and leaves only the
favourable personality traits. When
interacting with certain genres many historical figures end up being
gender bent in order to fit into the cast’s overall gender dynamic
and often end up highly exaggerated as a result. By far the rarest
use of them is as a reinterpretation of their real life counterparts,
this is different from an idealisation in that it tends to deviate
far more significantly from the source material and how they are
traditionally viewed by popular culture. Despite being potentially
well know to the player, historical figures offer a wide pool of
cliches to draw from leading
to some surprising and expressive characters being born. Let’s
travel through time and look at how our past can be put to work for
fiction.
Idealisation Of The Past
Reality
is a messy place where nobody remains entirely virtuous for long and
this is doubly true for the biggest figures in history. This leaves
visual novels with an interesting conundrum when using historical
characters, do they try to capture the person warts and all or do
they iron out the creases for the sake of the overall narrative. The
vast majority of titles choose the second option and present an
idealised version of the factual person so they do not have to deal
with unwanted moral complexity. If the individual in question already
has a cultural mythos surrounding them from other media, or the
culture more generally, then this approach of streamlining them is
almost guaranteed in order to adhere to audience expectations for
their character. Removing less desirable elements from a Historical Figure also makes it easier to create a likeable personality which
the player can bond with. When said
character is a romance interest this idealisation is often taken even
further since they must be attractive in a clean manner which is
impossible for a real person to achieve and this results in them
being focused around the core events and traits of their life. From a
broader stand point, this removal of negative elements helps a
narrative make its thematic point without the distraction of having
to justify the character’s more questionable actions while still
having a meaningful connection to the real world for the game to play
off.
To showcase this trend let’s look at one of visual novel’s
favourite groups the Shinsengumi and in particular three different
versions of Hijikata Toshizou to see how the same person can be
idealised in different ways. Bakumatsu Renka SHINSENGUMI’s version
leans heavily into him as a calm, calculated and serious man who
comes across as a bit prickly at first glance. Underneath this he is
someone who is intensely loyal and puts his complete trust in those
he chooses to believe in. This personality plays on the samurai ideal
which Hijikata Toshizou has come to represent in Japanese popular
culture while twisting it in such a way that it is easily framed
within the romantic context needed for his status as a suitor. It
also helps him cleanly stand out among the cast in a way which
contrasts against them while keeping intact a strong connection to
his historical counterpart.
Hakuouki’s Hijikata Toshizou has a
similar focus on being the strict and serious member of the
Shinsengumi, but with a greater emphasis on his mature kindness and
its connection to his honour. This version wants to come across as a
more believable and human idealisation which leaves him without the
extremes of many of his other incarnations. In part this is due to
the strong supernatural element of the narrative demanding a greater
anchor to prevent it from losing believability. However, there is
also a sense that what makes him romantically attractive should be
his vulnerability and humanity and this means putting in a few key
weakness into his traits that can come back to bite him.
Destined to Love: Ikemen Samurai Romances’ version
is by far the simplest with his historical identity being interpreted
as a serious workaholic. Yet he is at this least rigid here with a
self assured swagger dominating his time on screen and in his
relationship with the heroine. Being attractive is put front and
centre here with adhering to the idea of his historical counterpart
only thought of when considering how he fits in with the rest of the
cast. The result is a character who appears as more cliché than man
which is the game’s aim as it wants the flavour of the period
rather than the complexities of the people who lived through it. The
overarching omission in all of these versions is the questionable
nature of the Shinsengumi with them effectively being a secret police
force and having been part of some less than scrupulous events. Yet
this moral wrinkle would call into question these characters in a way
which would prevent them from being the morally righteous people
these stories demand.
Gender Bending Time
When
it comes to including Historical Figures in a visual novel, developers
have to consider their target market and make alterations in order to
align these characters with audience expectations. A common way this
appears in practice is through gender bending these people so the
game can have the desired number of each sex for their overall
purposes. This is most famously used to turn those who where
historically men into cute anime girls in titles aiming for a male
demographic. This can be done in order to obscure their real identity
or otherwise have them betray audience expectations, as is done in
the Fate franchise, so they can be used to reinforce the themes and
narrative through the surprise which comes from revealing said
identity. More commonly gender bending is just an excuse to create a
harem of girls loosely based on Historical Figures for the player to
either collect or make their way through the buffet. What both of
these share is the way these versions are extremely exaggerated to
the point of being mere caricatures of their original and they are made
up from only a few personality traits with realistic human
abrasiveness smoothed over. Having a simple presentation allows these
characters to invoke the idea of complexity from their real life
counterpart while still maintaining the curated features needed for
the kind of story the visual novel wants to tell.
Let’s examine a
couple of titles which make prominent use of gender bent historical
characters and get a sense for how they are constructed. Eiyuu * Senki
might well be the single visual novel with the most gender bent
Historical Figures in it to the point of this being a core part of
its identity. As a result of these numbers the game treats the
majority of the cast as collectables for the player to acquire and add to their harem. This means they
often have only one or two traits from their real life counterparts
since anything more would be a waste of time since the player will
not be able to hold numerous complex characters in their head and
quickly lose track of who is who without this simplification. Eiyuu *
Senki’s rendition of Alexander the Great is a good example of
treatment of the overall cast. She is a carefully curated selection
of elements from the real life Alexander formed in such a way as to
fit into her faction while standing out among the other girls. Each
one contributes to a singular picture of her, from her habit of
calling everything Alexandria to the horns on her head, they frame
her within parts of the truth brought to their extremes for comic
effect. At no point does she ever evolve beyond this outline and
instead further plays into it as a means of providing entertaining
mini events and silly conflicts.
Sengoku † Koihime ~Otome Kenran ☆
Sengoku Emaki~ takes another popular era of Japanese history, the
Sengoku Jidai, and transforms all its important men into women. The
main heroine is the warlord Oda Nobunaga and she encapsulates the
game’s approach to its Historical Figures. She has much of the
confidence and charisma attributed to her real life equivalent with
the game putting a lot of emphasis on her as a visionary leader who
is capable of inventive strategies. While she is allowed some room to
grow in relation to the protagonist and their bond, her overall
persona remains consistent and recognisable even across the multiple
entries in this series. Despite this she and the other heroines are
allowed a greater degree of humanity than any of those from Eiyuu * Senki
which avoids making them feel like collectables but not going too far
and losing their focused identities for the player to quickly
remember among the sea of others.
History Is What We Make Of It
Not
all Historical Figures are used within their original time and place
with there being a type of fiction which removes them from this
context and places them somewhere alien. This can be anywhere from
the distinct future to fantasy versions of their own history, but the
overall purpose of this change is to reinvent the historical
character. A major benefit to this approach is to be able to leverage
the established ideas about the person while also being able to break
from the original to create a new character without it coming across
as being unbelievable. This opens up the kind of stories which can be
told since the need to adhere to some kind of historical precedent
has be reduced to a loose sense of legitimacy gained from
association. Often these reinvented character are effectively
original to the game so they can use the legacy of the historical
person as a string board for exploring ideas and themes associated
with them. Every generation reinvents its heroes be they real or
mythological so it should be no surprise to see visual novels do the
same.
One game which takes this kind of character to its extreme is
Daibanchou -Big Bang Age-. Here the Historical Figures are placed
within the over the top nature of the title as a
means to further enhance this trait. It chooses people from throughout
history and slaps them into this new context as effectively new
characters which pushs their past through as silly a filter as
possible. Take Cleo Aripa, who is this game’s idea of Cleopatra,
rather than an adult woman as history remembers her, she is instead a child.
The confidence and allure her original was known for is reimagined as
a bratty overconfidence inline with her new appearance and suitably exaggerated to make it believable. Since she is given equal billing
alongside the completely original characters of the story, there is a
sense they belong instead of being external elements brought into
the mix which pushes the insanity of its narrative that little bit
further.
For a more serious example of what reimagining Historical
Figures can do we can look to Liar-Soft’s steampunk games. These
titles take people and move them around in history a bit under the
excuse of this alternate steampunk universe so they can be next to
other characters who better match the narrative’s needs. Sometimes
this leads to quite obvious changes as with Gahkthun of the Golden
Lightning -What a Radiant Brave-’s Nikola Tesla who only loosely
resembles his original through the association with electricity and a
few broader details of his earlier life. These can be subtler as with
Shikkoku no Sharnoth’s Mary Clarissa Christie were it is difficult
to pick out what has been altered unless you are already familiar
with the finer details of her life. Regardless of its implementation,
the reimagined characters keep enough of their historical connection
as is needed for the core themes of the game in question and work as
living manifestations to keep them in the player’s mind even when
not being talked about out-loud.
Conclusion
Blending
fact and fiction through borrowing from history has always been an
enticing prospect in storytelling and visual novels find themselves
forever drawn to grand outline of Historical Figures. These can be
polished into an idealised form better suited for the heroic or
romantic fantasies playing out on screen while still lending the
story a legitimacy. They might instead be reinvented into a new
setting or world so they can be divorced from their originals and still invoking themes and ideas from history. Or you could just swap
their gender in order to fit in with genre expectations while having a historical underpinning to keep things fresh. No matter what
a developer decides to do with their historical characters, they are
a varied and expressive way to explore the past and entertain the
player through the mixing of the familiar and new within these
characters.
The World Well: Blood of Caro Review – Blood Is Thinner Than Water
Genre – Science Fantasy, Dystopia, Yuri Play Time – 20 hours Developer – Basi Ningmeng Zhizuozu Steam VNDB
The Future Haunts The Past
Being
born a Caro has always been a curse for 4. An offspring of a human
and vampire, she, like many of her kind, was sold off as a child by
her human parent to be livestock for vampires. She was freed from
this life by the only person to show her love just for them to be
murdered pushing 4 onto the path of revenge. By a twist of fate she
ends up pulling the mechanical torso of a girl named Noma from the
wreckage of strange crash site. Noma claims to be for the future and
enlists 4’s help to change the past and avoid a catastrophe. Now 4
find herself caught between her hatred of the world which has taken
everything from her and the strange Noma who stimulates emotions in
her which she had forgotten she could feel. The slowly growing
bond between 4 and Noma is easily the greatest achievement of the
narrative with them acting as each other’s emotional support while
also hiding certain information from the other as they try to fool
themselves as much as their other half. This is underpinned by some
compelling world building and a strong set of themes and ideas which
comment on human nature alongside the problems plaguing the present
day. Acting all this out is a cast of well realised characters who
form the backbone supporting the main pair as well as the antagonists
out to undermine them and all this creates some tense encounters. Its visual
design bring the world to life with a cinematic flare which injects
life into the barren ruins and deserts 4 and Noma travel through.
However, this is not a game without issues, from its overuse of
flashbacks to events so dark and miserable they come around to being
comedy. Are these systemic problems enough to collapse the emotional
catharsis of this magical journey? Let’s drink some blood and find
out.
It’s Only Human Nature – Narrative and Themes
The
ups and downs of 4 and Noma’s relationship is the main
emotional through line of Blood of Caro and it is deftly weaved into
ongoing events in a way which solidifies its identity without
distracting from the moment to moment drama. Watching the pair
stubble in their interactions with one another as 4’s pragmatism
and Noma’s idealism clash which causes their respective
weaknesses bubbles up. All the while they are constantly trying to bridge the gap between
them. Their bond is also the greatest point of catharsis in the game since
when they overcome a hurdle their relationship the player cannot help
but cheer for them. All this ensures there is a consistent thematic
core of loss and guilt which the bigger events can rely on to
add stakes to their dangerous situations. This is backed up by a
superb ability to constantly and believably have the main characters
on the back foot in order to ensure tension is felt in every life or
death moment. Despite the future tech Noma can bring to bear, her
weakened state and its high power consumption mean she can easily be
overpowered by numbers, fire power or another less damaged time
traveller. The big factions of this world repeatedly prove to be far
more than the group can handle leading to a lot of running and hiding
as they desperately inch their way towards their goal. It results in
battles where the protagonists are just powerful enough to make it
a back and forth but not so strong as to be able to avoid any danger.
These highs and lows of emotion help give life to the extensive world building which is perfectly constructed to be
both oppressive and thought provoking in equal measure. A lot of
consideration has gone into how the social and physical aspects of
the world interlock to create its political landscape. This is everything
from a section of land in near permanent shadow being the heartlands
of the vampires to a strip of land between two empires carving out
its independence through playing both sides. It gives Blood of Caro a
feeling of life and being grounded in a reasonable reality which many
similar fantasy worlds lack and it helps invest the player in the
outcomes which threaten to tear it apart. All of this construction is
in service of making an environment capable to delivering some
carefully crafted criticisms of our own world and of human nature. It
acts out scenarios similar to ones which have played out in the
player’s own lifetime and forces a reflection on what this tells
them about the people involved and their motives. This is
extrapolated out from the terrible things personally witnessed by the
cast all the way to the broader ideological and philosophical ideas
underpinning how the human world works. Even its villains engage with
this dance as they win not through overwhelming power but by playing
humanity’s own nature against it. The overall messaging invites the
player to reflect on their own life and how they might be complicit
in the suffering of someone like 4 and asks who is really responsible
here.
As you might have gathered from the outline of the plot, this is a fair dark game which is not afraid to confront some truly terrible things. However, this is a double edged sword which it can sometimes cut itself on. There are multiple instance where terrible things happen back to back in such a short period of time that they come across as the universe using the characters as a punching bag. What this results in is making these sections accidentally funny since it moves over the line into be absurd almost to the of parody which hurts the tone that the game so desperately wants to invest the player in. Then there is the overuse of backstories and flashbacks which often grind the pacing to a halt as they extensively explain the past. This get absurd at some points with the an late game antagonist spending a good half of the finale just explaining their backstory through the longest flashback in the game. While this example is forgivable due to how important this information is to the main cast, it is part of a broader problem which constantly rears it head to take the player out of the present day they are actually interested in. Despite the high quality of the world building, it can sometimes tip over into useless information and further exasperate the pacing issues. These are things like events happening in the broader world which ultimately do not meaningfully impact the main cast or just minor nuggets of lore which would have been better left for a codex to explain. To top it all off, there is the strange choice to have the a major villain just sort of get away and vanish from relevancy. In the context of the finale this makes emotional sense since 4 and Noma have another antagonist who hits much closer to home as their final confrontation, but it still feels a little strange for such a terrible person to just receive no comeuppance. Leaving it hanging off the end of the story just leaves a weird taste in the mouth even if the ending is still satisfying overall.
Missing Limbs And Deep Scars – Characters
Even when separated from each other 4 and Noma make for compelling characters in their own right. 4 wildly swings between guarded cynicism to desperate vulnerability to gentle caring sometimes within the same scene. It is clear from the moment the game starts that she is just a house of cards waiting for a mild breeze to cause her to crumple. When she does it is spectacular collapse which plays wonderfully into the gradual process of rebuilding her identity at the core of the second half’s emotional journey. Noma is a similar mess of feelings but hers centre around the weight of her guilt. The upbeat and idealistic personality she presents to the rest of the cast is a fragile mask which she wears to convince herself, as much as them, of her own righteousness. Her arc is one of being able to forgive herself for the past and find something in her present worth living for. Accompanying this pair of protagonists are an entertaining selection of secondary characters, such as the horny lesbian Bani, who all work to contrast the main pair and showcase the flaws in their view of the world while also helping them grow. Each is given the screen time necessary to be likeable and have their own stories within the greater narrative yet only a few stick around for the long term keeping the overall cast fresh.
Further reinforcing the quality of the cast are the villains who swing between being monstrous and compelling as they clash against the heroes. Their actions remain framed at all times through the lens of their ideals which are shown time and time again to hold more truth than the cast is comfortable admitting. However, there is never any doubt as to their terrible nature what is instead asked is if they are a product of or the cause of the many issues plague this world. The only real problem with the cast come not in the form of any single member but rather in the absence of one. There is no major ‘good’ vampire character. A few vampires are presented sympathetically, but these are minor faceless characters on screen for no more than a few minutes at most. This leaves the majority of the vampire characters as unquestionably evil psychos and by extension presents the whole race as such. It seems like a missed opportunity to have a more well rounded impression of the vampire race, especially as a means of challenging 4’s world view, and it feels odd given how varied and interesting the human and Caro cast ended up being.
Wastelands Of Our Own Making – Visual, Audio and Technical
At
every opportunity Blood of Caro pushes aspects of ‘cinematic’
presentation and merges them into the deserts, medieval towns and
high-tech cities which occupy its visual space. These ‘cinematic’
elements include the regular use of intersected video, a love of
black bars and CGs focused around dynamic and exciting shot
composition. Each one provides a layer of unique identity to the game
with it invoking the style of movies to help frame its narrative in a
suitably grand scale while also keeping the personal and intimate
nature of visual novel for the key emotional moments. Visually it mixes the dirty and dusty world of
the continent with the techno-fantasy presentation of its magic and
science to sharply present the divide between them. Yet they never
appear so far apart from one another as to be from different worlds
since a lot of the visual styles of each overlap to make it clear
they belong side by side. All of this is done in the service of
subtly pushing the game’s core theming into every single scene. There are also a few fun extras like being able to change Noma’s
outfit which is amusing touch given she is a hologram for most of the
game and has a somewhat flexible appearance as a result.
When it
comes to the choices presented to the player there is an unevenness
to their presence throughout the narrative. At the beginning they are
a regular feature with meaningful differences in events depending on
what the player chooses, but they become increasingly sparse at about
the halfway mark before petering out entirely until a final
choice at then end. This makes the game feel very front loaded with
player expression and creates the sense that the later half is more
of a railroaded experience where the player is forced to be passive.
It allows for a weird unnecessary friction to seep into the player’s
engagement with the game which could have been avoided if it had a
consistent pacing of choices.
Conclusion
Human
nature and its consequences define much of how Blood Of Caro presents
its world and crafts the journey of its characters as they struggle
against what seems like an insurmountable challenge. As 4 and Noma’s
relationship slowly grows there are layers of commentary made about
this complex and imaginative world where danger is around every
corner. The overall cast bring different and entertaining view points
to enrich its thematic patchwork, from sympathetic allies to
terrifying villains, with each coming and going from the story in a
natural manner. Underpinning this is a ‘cinematic’ visual style
which invokes elements of film in the dusty ruins and the mixes medieval fantasy with steampunk science. It is not a title without
issues with an overuse of flashbacks and pushing its dark tone to the
point of accidental comedy and these do dampen the experience at
times. However, when you walk away from Blood of Caro these problems
will seem so minor in comparison to the compelling and thoughtful
journey which outshines all these stains.
Verdict –
Blood, revenge and fragile humanity define a thought provoking
and evocative tale of two girls as they struggle with their
hopes and sins. Although it does stumble at times in its love of
flashbacks and being so overly bleak as to be funny.
Pros -
+
4 and Noma’s relationship is a joy to watch unfold as their pair
become entangled in each other’s complex web of feelings.
+ A well realised world which defines the cast as much as they define it
and is a memorable place to journey through.
+
Has a complex and thoughtful commentary on human nature weaved into a
tapestry of tense action and fragile hope.
+
A cast of lively characters who clash and cooperate in believable and
entraining ways.
+
Mixing cinematic presentation with distinctive visuals results in a
feast for the eyes.
Cons -
-
Can be so dark at time that it accidental becomes a parody of itself.
-
Massively overuses flashbacks and often kills its own excellent
pacing.
Best Visual Novel Releases – October 2026
Now
the spooky time of the year has finally gone, we can leave the corners we were cowering in and return to the light of day where a wonderful
selection of visual novels are waiting for us. It has been a month
filled with a wave of interesting and inventive titles attempting to
push the medium forwards or recapturing a neglected sub-genre.
Everything from vampiric detective mysteries to photographic crime
thrillers have come home to roost and offer a little something for
all kinds of players. Let’s dive in and find out what you should be
playing from October’s releases.
Official Releases
LaurEli & The Blood Dipped Manor
Left
wheelchair bound after an accident, private detective Laura Le Fanu
goes to visit her uncle’s estate to recuperate but she gets more
than she bargained for in the form of the teasing butler Eli and the
sudden appearance of a “vampire” serial killer. The isolated
estate is the setting for a murder mystery where the player must
gather clues, interrogate witnesses and discover the truth about what
is really going on here. By far the biggest star of the show comes in
the form of Laura and Eli’s relationship which slowly evolves over
the game as they exchange witty banter and becomes the emotional
heart of the narrative. A solidly put together detective title with a
suite of likeable characters which will appeal to fans of the genre
and keep them engaged for its entire duration.
Meiji Tokyo Renka Twilight Kiss
Continuing
off from Meiji Tokyo Renka Full Moon, Twilight Kiss continues the
originals blend of reimagined historical figures and a strange
fantasy setting. Split between the various suitors from the first
game, the heroine finds themselves getting swept up in new incidents
which test her new found love in a variety of entertaining ways. It treads the line between fandisc style expansions of established dynamics
while also adding its own wrinkles to the world so it can stand out
in its own right. One firmly aimed at existing fans which assumes
affection for and knowledge of these characters with no effort being
made to re-establish its core ideas. However, the result is an
undeniably fun romance story that leverages its imagination to craft
some unforgettable moments.
Exhibition of the Heart
Since
this is already a Review on this title here on the blog, I
won’t spend too much time talking about it. This is entertaining
yuri story which uses it exhibitionism premise to explore the
insecurities and desires surrounding how we present ourselves. At its
core is a fear of being judged and this creates some powerful
emotional moments while hitting close to home due to its extremely
grounded setting. Overall, it makes for a short and sweet game with
enough heart to keep you entertained across its playtime.
AKIBA LOST
This
title is a mixture of FMV and visual novel in the same vein as 428:
Shibuya Scramble and seems to continue the legacy of this classic but
underserved niche. At its core it is a choice based story with lots
of different outcomes which reveal more about the overarching mystery
and leans into the idea of explore the narrative space rather than
simply heading straight to the end. One of the ways it encourages
this is through its multiple protagonists and swapping between them to get new
angles on the cast and events. The Akiba Vanishing and its present
day revival are a great pair of mysteries which both feed into each
other while also wonderfully misleading the player into assumptions
of their own making so allowing the big reveals of hit with the
necessary punch. If you are looking for something a little unusual in
the visual novel space then AKIBA LOST will provide a memorable
experience.
Sign: Broken Kether
A
fish out of water style game where a witch for another world named
Cygnus ends up in ours and meets Lyra, a typical high-school girl,
leading to a heart-warming relationship building between them. It
really lives and dies on how much the player likes this pair and
their banter since it is front and centre for the majority of the
play time. Fortunately their vastly differing perspectives on life
means the two clash and compliment each other in such a way that keeps
their bond feeling fresh throughout their journey together. Couple
this with some bright and colourful visuals and the result is a game
which firmly plants its flag, understands what it wants to be and
delivers it to the player in an uncompromised fashion. If this sounds
like something which would be up your alley then it will not
disappoint.
Exhibition Of The Heart Review – The Things We Do For Love
Genre – Yuri, Nukige Play Time – 3.5 hours Developer – Yuri Eureka Steam(18+) VNDB
Note – I received a review copy from the developer. Just a heads up.
Oops My Crush Is A Weirdo
Reconnecting
with your secret high-school crush is difficult at the best of times, but finding out they are a shameless exhibitionist makes it even more
awkward. This is a fact which Alice finds out first hand after
discovering Sylvia, the girl she idolised, deep in the forest and as
bare as the day they were born. Determined to finally confess to
Sylvia, Alice decides to get involved in Sylvia’s antics and the
pair begin their increasingly daring activities. It is in this
frantic attempt by Alice to get Sylvia to look at her where
Exhibition Of The Heart shines as the pair dance around their
feelings in their own little masquerade. Comedy underpins everything
and creates a light tone which compliments the likeable main
characters while allowing them the space to express themselves. The
warm and round visuals supplement this cosy story by enveloping the
player in a blanket of fantasy. Yet the narrative is capable of
creating some impactful moments when needed to help sell the
believable escalation in the pair’s relationship. Alice’s
insecurities become a constant companion throughout the experience
and being in her head offers an engaging contradiction between her
thoughts and how she acts around others. However, it is not without
its issues with some rough edges in the visual department which can
draw the player out of the moment. Are these imperfections enough to
ruin this tale of yuri escapades? Let’s take everything off and
find out.
Baring All To You – Narrative and Themes
The
many antics the main pair get up to over the course of their
exploration of exhibitionism are the star of the show. Each one
getting increasingly daring while playing into the humorous tone to
create some delightfully entertaining moments. Their primary
narrative purpose is to showcase the pair’s current relationship
through the way they clearly trust one another enough to get carried
away in their activities but at the same time lack the confidence to
truly be open about their feelings. A wonderful irony
exists throughout the early sections where they are baring everything
about their bodies yet both are lying to the other out of fear of
baring their hearts. These combine to keep the light-hearted banter
entertaining as the emotional vortex called Alice struggles to pull
herself together long enough to confess. Each of these events slowly build
up the overly idealised vision of Sylvia found in Alice’s head
while doing a good job of convincing the player that this is the
truth despite how absurd the initial fantasy seems.
Of course any
delusion like this is doomed to shatter on contact with reality and when this happens it is quite a spectacular and emotional punch which puts everything
they have done together into a new light. The climax to the story
knows how to up the stakes without entirely doing away with the game's tone and making it feel like everything is coming full circle. It
offers a surprisingly grounded problem for the pair to overcome where
the future they must face is murky and uncertain with the only light
forwards being their mutual love. It nicely reflects back on the
ideas of lying to others to make yourself look better by showing that
baring yourself in both body and heart can result in a more
meaningful relationship with another person than merely trying to impress them. While its
core messaging might be fairly simple it is delivered in a suitable
human package and placed into the context of our everyday lives giving
it the impact it needs to stay with the player.
Concealed Love – Characters
Alice
is front and centre of the narrative from the moment it starts and acts as a
lively protagonist with a memorable internal landscape. Often
indulging in flights of fantasy, she is perfect mix of impulsive and
insecure where what she wants clashes against her own self doubt to
create a debate as she desperately frets over what to
do in any given situations. Her monologues are some of the strongest
sources of humour in the game and set up her as a likeable character
even if she is not the smartest tool in the shed. This colourful
personality also works to shape the player’s impressions of both
her place in the world and of Sylvia whom she puts on a pedestal.
This innocent crush prevents her from properly seeing Sylvia which
leads to both the main conflict and also a lot of small moments of
levity.
Sylvia forms the other half of this romantic pairing
while being the straight man to Alice’s internal struggles. She
initially comes across as aloof and uncaring about what other people
think even after Alice catches her engaging in exhibitionism in the
woods. Yet she does care what Alice thinks about her and seems
at least in part aware of how Alice views her which she often plays
into. Initially it is her deciding on the increasingly wild things
they are going to do together making her appear to be the dominate
member of the pairing but over time the two shift around as they
begin to properly truth each other after their time apart. The slow
rebuilding of their dynamic into something new is the main focus of the character side of the narrative and it does a
good job of keeping things fresh as the pair test their boundaries.
All of this set up and strong characterisation is key to making the
big conflict at the climax have impact. It provides a suitable test
for everything the pair have built between them and plays off their personalities to reveal their hidden sides. Everyone beyond the main
pairing is just set dressing for their journey and are mostly
disembodied voices or silhouette people to drive this home.
Flesh And A Stiff Breeze – Visual, Audio and Technical
By
far the greatest point of improvement over Yuri Eureka’s previous
title are the visuals which help craft a soft and cosy atmosphere. Bright pastel colours seep into every aspects
of its aesthetic identity from the day time streets to the dark
forests with all of them lit up in their gentle hues. Accompanying
this is a broad use of curves across the visual design. The two
protagonists are noticeably round, soft and lacking in harsh edges
which lends them a feeling of being delicate and gentle. Everything
which can be rounded has found itself curved in some fashion and the
remaining harsh angles are alleviated by the aforementioned bright
colouring. These all come together to reinforce the warm and light
feeling the game is aiming for. The main pair have a good variety of
poses and clothing for their sprites to properly communicate the
daring activities they are engaging in. It also serves to make them
visually dynamic which is important give how much they are on screen
and makes it fun to see what their sprites will do next. A nice
inclusion is the sprite viewer and scene maker which unlocks upon
completing the game and it offers a great toy to mess around with to
create your own little moments.
However, despite all the improvements
to the visuals, it is also here where Exhibition Of The Heart’s
biggest issues emerge. The first of these are the many small visual
oddities which can be found throughout the game. These are mostly
things like minor incorrect proportions for some objects of parts of
people in CGs and a general rigidity to some character posing.
Nothing which ruins the moment but it is something the player will
notice over the course of the game. The second and bigger offender is
the character sprite of Samantha which looks off compared to the two
protagonists. She is a microcosm of all the broader visuals
inconsistencies throughout the game, slightly off body proportions
and a choice of pose which comes across as painful and unnatural.
Combine this with her only having only one expression and pose and
the result is a character who comes across more like an alien
pretending to be human than a believable person. Fortunately she is
only in the game for a couple of scenes so she does not really ruin
the experience, but it is distracting when she does appear.
Conclusion
Playing
around with the idea of exposing oneself, both figuratively and
literally, is one of Exhibition Of The Heart’s greatest strengths
and it has a lot of fun taking this concept to its extremes. It
creates a powerful irony in the main pair’s exhibitionism as they
conceal their hearts from each other and this leads to a wonderfully
impactful final conflict over their love. The pairing of Alice and
Sylvia results in a back and forth between Alice’s internal
delusions and Sylvia’s aloof responses which creates a fun dynamic
throughout the entire game. Visually and technically this a set up
from the studio's previous game and crafts a warm and gentle
atmosphere through its bright colours and constant curves. However,
it is also in the visuals where the biggest issues lie stemming from
inconsistencies and other minor problems. Thankfully they are
infrequent enough to not ruin the experience and ultimately only dent
what is a wild and entertaining yuri ride.
Verdict –
Wild antics and entertainingly dynamic characters bring to life a
vivid story of love and the fear of being judged. It has some rough
visual edges at times but nothing which ruins the experience.
Pros -
+
Leverages the exhibitionism to craft a tale of the contradiction
between what we show people and who we really are leading to a powerfully
emotional finale.
+
Alice and Sylvia are an absolute joy together and their interactions
lie at the heart of the game’s appeal.
+
Strong visual direction and a number of fun post game extras make for
memorable atmosphere.
Cons -
-
Minor visual inconsistencies in terms of proportions, awkward posing
and other such elements do distract at times.
Quizzes – Uncovering The Hybrid
Answering The Pressing Questions
An
often overlook yet extremely common mechanic in games is the Quiz
with its simple multiple choice questions demanding the player rack
their brains. The tendency visual novels to focus their entire structure and identity around presenting various options means
Quizzes have often found themselves a home as part of their overall
means of engagement. Rather than being an outlet for trivia, which a
Quiz game might be on its own, it is instead repurposed to push
in-universe ideas and concepts through a familiar lens. This can be
as simple as being a tool to make sure the player has been paying
attention and knocking them awake. More often than not it is utilised
as a means of simulating the process of deduction in many mystery or
detective games which can exist alongside or in replacement for other
mechanics pushing the same idea. They can also create a form of tension when the visual novel suddenly asks something designed to
unsettle the player or require them to be answer in a short window if they
want to survive. Let’s get ready to press that buzzer and find out
how this pairing works in practice.
Poking The Player
In
its most basic form a Quiz serves the function of checking the player
has been paying attention and tests them on facts about what they
have witnessed. It acts as a shock to the system to signal the player
should be paying closer attention if they do not want the game to
hand out a failing grade. Despite this being a basic
motivator it can be surprisingly effective since nobody likes to feel
like they are dumb and the everyone wants to believe they are smart
which is what a Quiz inherently feeds its mechanics on. This carrot
and stick approach is tame enough to not make the player feel as if
they must have a perfect score but it is has enough teeth so that
they are likely to have a greater awareness of the narrative going
forwards. Such Quizzes tend to be infrequent in nature due to how
they completely break up the flow of events and are mostly
concentrated at the end of distinct sections of the story where they
occupy a nature pause in momentum.
XBLAZE LOST:MEMORIES is the poster
child for this kind of Quiz in visual novels. At regular intervals it
takes the player into a space separate from the narrative where it
has its cast act out of character and it has the protagonist be part of a quiz
show about the story events they have just witnessed. This exists so
the game can ensure the player is keeping up with its increasingly
complex plot points and concepts by repeating them and highlighting
which ones are important through their questions. A similar concern
about the player’s understanding of complex narrative beats can be
seen in Schrödinger's Call where Mary will stop after every call and
quiz the player in the form of an internal monologue about what they
just witnessed. What these two games showcase is how the Quiz can
break down ideas and events into more manageable chunks to keep it
from becoming overwhelming. However, it also risks appearing to
patronise the player by treating them with a sense that they lack the
intelligence to follow these narratives without assistance which can
accidentally antagonise them.
A way to mitigate this is to frame it
as being related to what the protagonist is learning alongside the
player as is done in The Expression Amrilato. It regularly asks the
player to apply the bits of Esperanto they have learned to help
Takatoo Rin on her journey of communication. Focusing on a positive
and productive aspect of Rin’s story allows the game to add some
weight to the Quizzes through a gradual escalation in what they are
asking both parties to achieve. Esperanto is not a commonly taught
language so the player is likely to be learning it through the game
for the first time and this lets the game side step the issue of
patronising the player since all this will be new to them. All three
titles here present their Quiz elements in a simple fashion which
sits somewhat to the side of the rest of the visual novel where
success or failure is ultimately not the point of their existence and
so treats it in the same detached manner.
Stand-In For Deduction
When
taking a Quiz you are being tested on your knowledge and ability to
recall details about information from past experiences. By extension
any kind of deduction starts with a series of questions to establish
the when, where, who, what and why of a situation which nicely covers
the requirements of a Quiz. This means it is easy to overlap
answering questions and the process of logical reasoning leading the
Quiz to be a common means of systematising a detective’s path to
catching a criminal or uncovering a mystery. Rather than presenting
it as a series of questions, this style of Quiz is mingled into the
character’s internal dialogue to frame it as them breaking down a
problem into solvable chunks. It also serves the purpose of making
the player feel clever since they are the ones who are answering the
questions which even the detective is struggling with so allowing
them a feeling of being intellectually superior. Their simple structure gives this kind of Quiz the ability to fit into any space
where the illusion of deduction is needed without having to dedicate
time to implementing more complex mechanics which may not be
appropriate for the kind of story being told.
Since this is so
flexible and often makes up a small part of the overall mechanical
landscape, it is best to cover a broad spread of examples in a simple
fashion to best demonstrate this trend. Let’s start with the two
most obvious visual novels employing this kind of Quiz, Danganronpa
and Phoenix Wright and compare their similar implementations. Both
include Quiz elements intermittently as part of a series of mechanics
which symbolise the process of deduction. They are mostly applied
to questions with obvious answers or those with big dramatic effects
which the player needs to witness immediately rather after a separate
play area has finished. They use the Quizzes during their respective
‘trial’ sections and this leads them to being a means of pushing
forwards to the truth giving the sequence a sense of momentum when
needed to keep the player engaged.
In some games the Quiz can end up
merged with other gameplay mechanics and it does in Yurukill: The
Calumniation Games. Here the Quiz takes place in and around the main
mechanic of being a top down shooter where the player is asked to answer
questions using the top down flight to go into the answer they want.
Seamlessly integrating it like this allows the game to maintain its
core focus and identity rather then bringing everything to a halt to
present its options and creates a greater sense of flow as a result.
Of course making the Quiz stand out is also an option and one which
FLOWERS -Le volume sur été- embraces to sell the stages of
deduction. It uses them to very directly signal significant jumps in
logic presented through the overall lining of flowers to keep it from
feeling too beyond the rest of the content. Being so direct gives
FLOWERS the ability to provide the feeling of intellectual catharsis and cleanly reward the player for their keen attention
with a pat on the back.
Asking For Tension
When
a person is suddenly asked a question they were not expecting there
is a moment of panic before their brain pulls up the answer and
capitalising on this through a Quiz can add extra drama to a scene.
In order to make this possible the choices are often accompanied by a
timer ticking down to create a sense of pressure to forceable induce
the desired anxiety and maybe even have the player commit to a
mistake. Picking the wrong option can often result in the death of
the characters in order to give the player’s actions and panic a
sense of weight and consequence. However, there is no doubt this is a
cheap trick to pull and risks annoying the player since they will
feel they were not given a fair chance to pick correctly. As such
this kind of Quiz is rarely used and is only really found in horror
titles where the pacing and demand for tension allow it to nicely
slot into a wider suite of mechanics. Even here it has to tread
carefully or fear can give way to frustration at the inability to
progress due to an artificial barrier and this is mitigated through
providing the information needed to solve it almost immediately
beforehand. After all the point is to create tension not to actually
test the player’s ability to recall past details so avoiding
anything too mentally taxing in this stressful situation prevents
unnecessary friction.
A title which demonstrates the both the
strengths and issues of this use of Quizzes is Death Mark. It
regularly picks at the player’s brain under a tense and time
constrained pressure where the monster of the day is breathing down
their neck. Sometimes failure in these results in an instant game
over while in others the negative effects are delayed in order to
keep the player on their toes and prevent them for growing
comfortable. For the most part the game
carefully chooses information for its Quizzes from recent areas so it
is easy to recall and allows the feeling of tension to not boil over
into anger. However, for some later sections it assumes culturally
specific knowledge not present in the game itself and asks the player
to answer its questions based on it. To
its original Japanese audience this would have been a reasonable
expectation but when transferred into another culture all of this is
lost and the only thing left is confusion and a bad taste in the
mouth. Future games in the series make sure to never repeat this
mistake and it shows just how aware the developers are of the fine
line they were treading in Death Mark leading to chances being made
to avoid overstepping again.
Conclusion
Twenty
questions might not a first glance seem to be something compatible
with visual novels yet their common choice based nature opens them up
to a flexible overlapping. Their main purpose is to act as a
mechanical way to stimulate the player without having to go into more
complex systems and they help break up any feels of monotony. Add some
timers and a death if the player does not get the answer right and
the Quiz can create tension during the scramble to recall the correct
information. It can also be an intellectual stand-in when dealing with deduction where the player gets to feel smart and puts themselves into the
head space of a detective. Overall it is an extremely adaptable
style of gameplay which every developer should consider using if they
want a small addition to the standard choice based structure of their
visual novel.






















